Should You Attack or Spare Captain Aelfyr in Avowed?

In Avowed, the decision to attack or spare Captain Aelfyr during the "A Path to the Garden" quest presents a strategic dilemma. This guide analyzes the consequences of each choice.

Attacking Captain Aelfyr yields significant rewards, primarily the unique Death Knight Gloves. These gloves are particularly beneficial for defenders and elemental fighters, offering a 10% reduction in stamina cost while blocking and a 15% boost to frost damage.

Beyond the gloves, eliminating Aelfyr grants access to additional loot: a Garnet, 26 Silver Fenning coins, Exceptional Scale Armor, and an Exceptional Greatsword. These high-quality items provide a substantial gear upgrade, especially for players who haven't prioritized equipment enhancements. Furthermore, you can loot the fallen Steel Garrote soldiers.

Conversely, sparing Aelfyr offers no tangible rewards. The challenge of the encounter itself—a difficult battle against melee fighters and healing mages—might be considered the implicit reward for players seeking to avoid a challenging fight. This choice may be preferable for lower-level characters, who can temporarily adjust the game's difficulty. The impact on Giatta's disposition is minimal, resulting in only minor conversational differences.

In conclusion, attacking Captain Aelfyr is the strategically advantageous option in Avowed, providing valuable loot and equipment upgrades. However, players may choose to spare her based on their preferred playstyle and character level.