Should You Side With Semine or Hashek in Kingdom Come Deliverance 2? (Necessary Evil Quest Guide Best Outcome)

In Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2's pivotal "Necessary Evil" quest, players face a difficult moral dilemma: siding with Semine or Hashek. This guide navigates the complexities of this choice, offering insights into interrogation strategies, battle choices, and the ultimate consequences of your actions.

Quest Walkthrough:

Following the "Back in the Saddle" quest, "Necessary Evil" begins with von Bergow tasking Hans and Henry to gather intelligence from Nebakov Fortress and interrogate a captured prisoner. The interrogation's outcome dictates whether von Bergow targets Semine or Nebakov. This walkthrough focuses on the Semine path, presenting the most challenging moral decisions.

Prisoner Interrogation:

Successful interrogation hinges on passing Speech checks. Options include:

• "We’ll put in a good word for you." (Requires 20 Impression)
• "Istvan and I are old acquaintances." (Requires 20 Impression)
• "Otherwise, it’ll end badly for you." (Requires 17 Intimidation)

Alternatively, torture can extract information. The interrogation reveals Semine's complicity with bandits. Reporting this to von Bergow initiates the attack on Semine, while withholding this information leads to an attack on Nebakov.

Attacking Semine or Nebakov:

Choosing to attack Semine leads to further difficult decisions involving Hashek. Attacking Nebakov avoids the Semine conflict, concluding the quest swiftly. While avoiding bloodshed at Semine is tempting, ignoring Semine's culpability in innocent deaths presents a moral quandary. The guide recommends attacking Semine, despite the potential consequences. Crucially, remaining with the party during the ride to Semine is vital; otherwise, the entire town will be massacred.

Siding with Semine or Hashek:

Before the attack, a conversation with Hashek reveals his thirst for revenge against Semine, advocating for extreme violence. The choice is clear:

• "Hashek is right." (Sides with Hashek)
• "Olda deserves a trial." (Sides with Semine)

The guide suggests siding with Semine. While Semine's actions were wrong, Hashek's scorched-earth approach results in further innocent casualties. This aligns with a morally upright playthrough. Siding with Hashek results in the town's complete destruction. Additionally, a decision regarding Olda's fate (life or death) arises within the tower.

Reporting to von Bergow:

Finally, Henry and Hans report to von Bergow. The choice is to remain silent, letting Hans handle the diplomacy, or to speak up. The guide recommends silence, allowing Hans's diplomatic skills to maintain favor with von Bergow, leading to the planned attack on Nebakov.

This comprehensive guide helps players navigate the moral complexities of Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2's "Necessary Evil" quest, offering recommendations for optimal outcomes and ethical considerations. Remember to consult additional resources for further game insights, including romance options and item locations.